May 4, 2009 12:00 PM

In the first 100 days of President Barack Obama’s administration, we’ve heard time and again about how so-called ‘green jobs’ are the solution to our nation’s economic woes. In his State of the State Address, Missouri Governor Jay Nixon called green jobs the “next-generation” of Missouri’s economy.  Across the board, Democratic politicians have been quick to stake our economic recovery on the creation of a new ‘green economy.’

Yet in Spain, the economy suffered when efforts to create green jobs destroyed nearly 110,000 jobs in other industries according to a study released last month from Spain’s King Juan Carlos University.  It suggests that the Democrats’ plan for economic renewal through ‘green collar’ jobs may hurt the economy far more than it helps. Gabriel Calzada Alvarez, a professor of applied environmental economics, explains that Spanish citizens currently suffer from higher taxes, more public deficit and ever-increasing energy prices—all the result of the government’s efforts to create a green economy. 

This study found that consumers paid much higher prices for home electricity due to government-mandated use of premium priced green energy.  In turn this caused many employers to leave the country in search of cheaper energy elsewhere.  After accounting for the increased cost of electricity and the government expenditure used to create the new green jobs, Calzada estimates that the Spanish spent $774,000 for each job created.

(Story continues below.)


Calzada warns that if the U.S. were to follow the same path as Spain, we should expect the same economic woes.  Specifically, Calzada said every green collar job created in the U.S. would result in the loss of 2.2 jobs that could have been created elsewhere with those same resources. In addition to this loss, Calzada explained that only one in ten green jobs would be permanent.  Calzada points out that Microsoft and Google have already moved their servers across the Canadian border to take advantage of cheaper Canadian energy. 

President Obama’s 2010 budget proposal includes about $20 billion dollars in tax incentives for clean-energy programs.  Dr. Calzada estimates that if the Administration fulfills its promise to create between 3 and 5 million green jobs, the program would result in the direct loss of 6.6 to 11 million existing jobs.

We’re already in a recession—as consumers, we simply can’t afford to subsidize green energy projects. Renewable energy consumes an enormous amount of taxpayer resources in its production, and in the end, still results in a higher cost to consumers. Here in Missouri, AmerenUE pushed hard for the state legislature to pass the Missouri Clean and Renewable Energy Construction Act. This bill would have permitted utility companies to increase customer rates—and bypass a mandatory approval process with the Missouri Public Service Commission—so long as increase was in the name of creating green energy projects. This bill promoted the very kind of programs that have ruined the Spanish economy. Luckily for Missourians, it died in the legislature last week.

As we look into our economic future, it’s important that we base our plans for recovery on sound economic principles. Research shows that green jobs won’t help us—they’ll hurt us. Obama and Nixon should take heed of this study and produce realistic, viable plans for our economic future.   

Marcus Bowen is a senior at the University of Missouri-Columbia and a former vice president of the MU College Republicans.  He also serves with the Jackson County Republican Party.


Letter to the editor Comments Bookmark and Share RSS News

Reader Comments (1)
I do not know why people are surprised about this. Obama did not dislike gas at $5 / gallon he just wished it would get there a litle slower. He and the democrats will be willing to destroy our economy to drive energy to a cost level that alternative fuels will be competitieve. Say hello to $8 / gallon
5/8/2009 5:05:52 PM  Lee Pittman  

Gabriel Calzada Alvarez, a professor of applied environmental economics, said every green collar job created in the U.S. would result in the loss of 2.2 jobs...

Home | TMR Blog | Forum | Subscribe | Search | About | Contact | Site Map

© The Missouri Record. All Rights Reserved.